2 Timothy 2:3 Thou therefore endure hardness, as a good soldier of Jesus Christ.
The Self-Refuting Proposition
The claim that absolute truth does not exist is a self-refuting proposition that borrows the absolute laws of logic from God while simultaneously denying His reality.
Apologetics AAR: The Denial of Absolute Truth
1. The Event & The Steel Man
-
The Objection: Absolute truth is an illusion; truth is merely a pragmatically evolving social construct, making any claim to know absolute truth an act of arrogant hubris.
-
The Steel Man: Human knowledge is inherently finite, culturally conditioned, and linguistically mediated; therefore, declaring universal, immutable truth confuses localized consensus with ultimate reality and imposes dogmatic certainty where only human convention exists.
2. Worldview & Logical Analysis
-
False Assumptions: Relativism presupposes autonomous human epistemologies, the myth of intellectual neutrality, and the unproven premise that transcendent divine revelation cannot occur.
-
Logical Fallacies:
-
Self-Refuting Fallacy (Begging the Question): It issues an absolute truth claim to declare that no absolute truths exist.
-
Bait and Switch (Equivocation): It redefines objective truth as mere subjective social utility.
-
Bulverism / Ad Hominem: It attacks the supposed psychological motive (”hubris”) of the claimant rather than evaluating the objective validity of truth itself.
-
-
Validity & Soundness: The argument is invalid and unsound because its central premise contradicts its own assertion, committing immediate logical suicide.
3. The Rebuttal (Logic & Scripture)
-
Logical Deconstruction:
-
The proposition “There is no absolute truth” violates the Law of Non-Contradiction (A=A and does not = A at the same time and in the same sense) and the Law of Excluded Middle.
-
If the statement is absolutely true, the claim is instantly false.
-
If it is merely a social construct, it carries zero universal authority and can be dismissed without evidence.
-
Knowledge of absolute truth is not human pride, but humble submission to God’s self-attesting revelation.
-
-
Scriptural Authority:
-
John 17:17 – “Sanctify them through thy truth: thy word is truth.”
-
Titus 1:2 – “In hope of eternal life, which God, that cannot lie, promised before the world began;”
-
Proverbs 22:20–21 – “Have not I written to thee excellent things in counsels and knowledge, That I might make thee know the certainty of the words of truth…”
-
4. Tactical Responses & Questions
-
Robust Responses:
-
“Is that statement itself an absolute truth, or just your own cultural social construct?”
-
“Claiming to know with certainty that no one can know absolute truth is the ultimate form of intellectual hubris.”
-
“I do not boast in human wisdom; I submit to what the God who cannot lie has revealed in His written word.”
-
-
Challenging Questions:
-
Are you absolutely certain that there is no absolute truth?
-
If truth is merely a social construct, by what objective standard do you judge anything as truly right, wrong, or false?
-
If society decided tomorrow that oppression was beneficial, would that make oppression objectively true and good?
-
Why are you using the universal, unchanging laws of logic to argue against the existence of universal, unchanging truth?
-